Economists and market strategists are increasingly questioning the Federal Reserve’s preference for higher interest rates, arguing that policymakers may be relying on inflation figures that fail to reflect recent market developments. A steep decline in gasoline, oil and other commodity prices suggests that inflationary pressures could already be weakening.
The criticism centers on the Fed’s dependence on delayed economic indicators, particularly the Consumer Price Index (CPI) and Producer Price Index (PPI). Both reports capture price movements from the previous month, potentially leaving policymakers behind as market conditions change.
Meanwhile, forward-looking indicators such as gasoline futures, refining margins and prices at fuel stations are providing a different picture, pointing toward further declines in energy costs.
“Inflation is a lagging indicator. It tells you what you paid last month. The crack spread is a leading indicator. It tells you what you’ll pay next month. One says inflation is too high. The other says it’s already falling. The Fed is listening to the first one. It’s about to hike into falling prices at the pump,” said Thierry Borgeat, co-founder and chief investment officer of Zurich-based asset manager Arvy, which operates under the supervision of Swiss financial regulator FINMA.
The debate over additional rate increases is particularly important for Bitcoin, as tighter monetary policy generally reduces investor appetite for volatile assets. Recent comments from Fed officials and the minutes of their October meeting have added to concerns about further tightening.
The October meeting minutes, published Wednesday, revealed that almost all participating officials believed additional increases in the federal funds rate could become necessary in the coming months. Their assessment was based on expectations for inflation and employment, with the objective of bringing inflation back to the central bank’s 2% goal.
Two officials also indicated that a December increase exceeding 25 basis points could be necessary if upcoming inflation readings were unfavorable. One basis point equals 0.01 percentage point, meaning 25 basis points represent a standard quarter-percentage-point adjustment.
Fed Governor Christopher Waller expressed support for a 50-basis-point increase in December during an interview with CNBC on Wednesday. Such a move would be twice the usual rate adjustment.
Governor Michael Barr also suggested that additional tightening might be appropriate, while San Francisco Fed President Mary Daly supported a more measured approach to monetary policy.
Higher borrowing costs can slow economic activity, reduce available liquidity and discourage investment in risk-sensitive assets such as Bitcoin.
However, critics argue that policymakers are giving excessive weight to October’s CPI and PPI readings. Although those reports showed inflation spreading across several categories of goods and services, they do not incorporate the latest weakness in energy and broader commodity markets.
Energy costs have played a significant role in driving inflation since the Iran war started in early March.
Falling crack spreads indicate weaker fuel inflation
The latest movements in refining margins are adding to the argument that inflation could be cooling faster than official data suggests.
The crack spread measures the difference between the price refiners pay for crude oil and the revenue they receive from selling refined products such as gasoline and diesel. It is widely used to assess profitability across the refining industry.
A popular benchmark is the 3-2-1 crack spread, which assumes that three barrels of crude oil are processed into two barrels of gasoline and one barrel of diesel.
A contraction in this measure generally signals that refined fuel prices are falling more rapidly than crude oil prices. This often creates conditions for lower wholesale and retail gasoline prices.
Figures provided by James E. Thorne, chief market strategist at wealth management firm Wellington Altus, showed that the 3-2-1 crack spread had declined 36% over six weeks.
The measure dropped from $65.56 per barrel to $41.90 as of Wednesday, highlighting the sharp deterioration in refining margins.
Thorne believes the decline reflects a growing imbalance in fuel markets. Previously attractive refining profits encouraged companies to increase production, but the resulting supply has begun putting downward pressure on gasoline and diesel prices.
He also pointed to a roughly 20% decline in wholesale RBOB gasoline futures and retail fuel prices of approximately $3.78 per gallon.
RBOB futures represent wholesale gasoline prices traded on the NYMEX. They recorded declines of 11.1% and 6.1% during the last two completed weeks, resulting in a combined decrease of around 16.5%.
The contracts have dropped another 4.4% so far this week, bringing their three-week losses close to 20%. CoinDesk’s review of TradingView data shows that this represents the sharpest decline since March 2020.
The downward trend is also becoming visible to American motorists. AAA reported that the national average price of regular gasoline reached $3.75 per gallon on Thursday.
That figure represents a 12.8% decrease compared with a month earlier and a 4.9% decline over the past seven days. Nevertheless, gasoline remains approximately 22% more expensive than it was at the same time last year.
Thorne expects retail fuel prices to decline further because changes in wholesale markets generally take several weeks to reach consumers.
He estimated that every 10-cent reduction in gasoline prices could bring headline CPI down by roughly nine basis points. Based on this trend, November could produce a negative headline inflation reading, while the March year-over-year comparison would exclude the earlier energy price surge linked to the war.
According to Thorne, the current weakness reflects an oversupply of refined products rather than a deterioration in demand. He argued that declining energy costs are already helping the Fed’s inflation-fighting efforts without requiring additional interest-rate increases.
Commodity ETFs reflect broader market weakness
The decline in gasoline and crude oil prices is not an isolated development. Several other commodity-linked investments have also experienced substantial losses this month.
Ryan Detrick, chief market strategist at Carson Investment Research, examined commodity exchange-traded fund performance through Wednesday’s market close. These ETFs primarily track futures contracts, meaning their returns can differ from the underlying spot prices of commodities.
Gasoline ETF UGA has declined 20.9% month to date, while the United States crude oil fund (USO) has fallen 19.4%. The Brent crude ETF (BNO) has recorded an 18.7% loss.
The weakness extends to broader commodity markets. Commodity funds have dropped approximately 12%, while copper ETF CPER has declined 12.5%.
Agricultural commodities have also moved lower, with wheat ETF WEAT losing 4.6% and corn ETF CORN falling 2.7%. Gold ETF GLD has declined 4.1% over the same period.
Natural gas has been a notable exception, rising 16.9% during November.
These widespread declines have fueled speculation that the Fed’s hawkish position may be disconnected from the latest developments in commodity markets.
James Lavish, co-managing partner of Bitcoin Opportunity Fund, questioned why policymakers were discussing a potential 50-basis-point rate increase despite clear signs of easing energy-related inflation.
He suggested that the Fed’s aggressive rhetoric could be designed to pressure financial markets before officials eventually decide to end their rate-hiking campaign.
Meanwhile, interest-rate futures are pricing in a 25-basis-point increase in December, another quarter-point move in January and a further potential increase by April.





